We’ve written a few times about community-building and the need for third spaces this year, highlighting bookish events in Toronto, including silent book clubs, and third spaces like Book Bar. This time, we wanted to speak to the person behind one of the city’s most popular community and fandom spaces: Jessica Sorrentino, aka Quizmaster Jess.
Jessica Sorrentino is a Toronto-based emcee and host. She’s been an iconic figure in the Toronto trivia scene for the past 9 years, and officially launched her company, Quizmaster Jess, in 2021. It has quickly grown to be one of the most recognizable trivia brands in the city, operating in venues across Toronto with a team of 8 hosts. Their trivia events include weekly general pub quizzes, and special events with niche themes, from Heated Rivalry to Vampire Diaries.
Jess, alongside Simona Stallone, also co-founded The Book Girls Toronto in May 2024. Together, they create spaces for “women to unapologetically like the things we like”. They host a monthly Trivia & Book Club Social and a rotation of other events and meetups, and have been described as “your book club’s favourite book club”.
Jess’ trivia events average 60-70 people per event, and frequently sell out. There is clearly a demand for these events, so we were excited to chat with Jess to learn more about her community-building efforts.
SheDoesTheCity (SDTC): Can you tell us a bit about how Jessica became Quizmaster Jess?
Jessica Sorrentino (JS): I wasn’t looking to be a trivia host — it started very organically. I was serving at a bar, and I started hosting trivia there casually — my first trivia theme that I ever hosted was The Mindy Project back in 2017 (one of my all-time favourite sitcoms). A couple of years later, a group of women attendees pulled me aside, and told me what I was doing was special. They gave me a $50 bill, told me to order business cards that week, and email them once I did. Now, 8 years later, thanks to a community that grew with me along the way, I have 12+ locations, about 8 trivia hosts on my team with over 25 events per month. Never in a million years would I have predicted I would be a professional trivia host. What I wasn’t expecting was the community building that came along with it.
I started by hosting themes I was obsessed with, but it quickly grew into what the community wanted. I would listen to my audience, immerse myself in the fandom, and create spaces for themes they wanted to see too. That’s actually how I got into romance reading — from my audience asking for a Fourth Wing & Iron Flame trivia!

SDTC: Can you talk a bit about The Book Girls, and how you got started?
JS: It’s hard to make friends as adults. For women, there are not many spaces to unapologetically be ourselves, be weird, be loud, and not tone ourselves down. Post-COVID, people were looking for human connection. I started adding a ticket option to join a “community table”, where you were encouraged to come solo or with a friend, and form a larger team, meeting other people who like what you like. At A Court of Thorns and Roses Trivia there were over 20 solo sign-ups. I was shocked at the turnout, because at that point it was so far out of my comfort zone to think about going to a bar to play trivia alone. But I had created a space where people felt comfortable to do that.
I realized people weren’t only coming to play trivia, they were actively searching for places to make friends. I asked the room what they wanted, and resoundingly it was a book club, at its heart a place to hang out and make connections. One of those sign-ups that I met there was Simona Stallone, and she was passionate about making that book club happen. Together we founded The Book Girls Toronto.
SDTC: Your company now hosts 3-5 themed and general trivias per week, with your themed trivia events often selling out pretty quickly. Why do you think people love trivia events?
JS: There are two aspects that create the draw — first is trivia itself. It is FUN. It’s learning but without the pressure of grades — it’s fun facts. It’s a casual activity to do with friends, and an easy weeknight post-work hang.
Secondly, it’s the fandoms and community. We all are fans of something. A lot of our fandoms are enjoyed in solitude. The opportunity to be in a room full of people who share the love of something means you are walking into an instant community — something we all crave. While I may not understand every fandom, I deeply understand being a fan. I built a team with a diverse range of interests and fandoms, so even if I’m not the biggest fan of something, I have the biggest fan running that trivia for you. It is an important part of my business model to make these authentic spaces. For example, at Twilight Trivia, you’re never going to have a host that makes fun of you for liking Twilight. It is going to be a shared safe space of fans celebrating and loving their favourite thing.

SDTC: What does a day in the life of a professional quizmaster & book club host look like?
JS: My days are all VERY different. I try to use different days for different tasks, so some days I’m doing a Hunger Games movie marathon and writing questions. Other days I’ll lock in at a coffee shop and launch 5 events, making graphics, writing descriptions. Oh and EMAILS, so many emails, fielding inquiries, theme requests, ticket switches, etc.
SDTC: What is your favourite part of what you do?
JS: I love being in a room sharing in the tangible energy of people who all love the same thing. It’s honestly an adrenaline rush. When I’m challenged on a question (because with superfans there WILL be a challenge), watching the scene on the screen to get to the bottom of it is exhilarating.
I also love talking to people about the topics — asking the room their opinion, sometimes passing the mic around. I know it’s cheesy, but my all-time favourite thing is people smiling when they leave. When people come up to hug me goodbye even if I just met them, or send me a DM saying thank you. And the ultimate is people attending an event together after meeting at one of my events before.

SDTC: What are you reading? What are some of your favourite books?
JS: I’m currently deep in my re-read of Sarah J. Maas’ Crescent City series. Some favourite books include The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy by Brigitte Knightley, anything by Danielle L Jensen; Ruby Dixon’s Ice Planet Barbarians series, and Ella Enchanted by Gail Carson Levine.
SDTC: Your career and your platform have grown pretty substantially over the years, and you’ve managed to build a dream career for yourself. Do you have any moments that you really felt like you “made it”?
JS: Definitely when Rachel Reid came to my Heated Rivalry trivia, and I had friends in Australia telling me they saw me on national news! That was surreal to say the least. That all happened because of a Toronto Public Library event, where I met and interviewed Rachel Reid. When I launched the trivia nights she reached out and asked to come (fastest yes in the world). The other time that stands out was after our first year as The Book Girls Toronto, we hosted a holiday end-of-year social to say thank you. We had some of our attendees reach out and send thank-you emails. Simona and I both called each other so excited knowing that what we built wasn’t just fun, it mattered to people, and that matters to us.
To find out more, you can visit Quizmaster Jess’ website, or find Quizmaster Jess or The Book Girls on Instagram.

Follow Us On Instagram